AV Processor With Separate Amps or AV Receiver?

When you're building a new home theater, it can be difficult to determine if you should get an AV processor with dedicated amps, just a receiver with built-in amplification, or an AV receiver mixed with dedicated amps. Here are some pros and cons for both:

Pros with AV Processor:

Customization: Tailored for audiophiles who prefer to choose specific amplifiers and speakers.

1. Modularity: Allows for independent upgrades of amplifiers and other components.
2. Higher Audio Quality: Focuses on delivering superior audio performance with advanced DACs and processing.
3. Future-Proofing: Equipped with advanced connectivity options and processing capabilities for long-term compatibility.

Cons:

1. Cost: Generally more expensive due to the need for additional amplification components.
2. Complex Setup: Requires more effort to set up and configure due to multiple components.
3. Additional Components: Users need to purchase separate amplifiers and possibly other components, adding to the overall cost and complexity.
4. Limited Integration: May lack built-in streaming services or other convenient features found in AV receivers, necessitating additional devices.

Pros with AV Receiver:

1. All-in-One Solution: Integrates amplification, audio/video processing, and often streaming capabilities into a single unit for convenience.
2. Ease of Setup: Ready to connect to speakers and other devices out of the box, making setup simpler.
3. Cost-Effective: Offers better value for users who don't require extensive customization or high-end audio features.
4. Integrated Features: Includes built-in streaming services, room calibration systems, and other features for enhanced convenience.

Cons:

1. Less Customization: Provides fewer options for customization compared to AV processors.
2. Lower Audio Quality: While still capable of good sound, may not match the audio performance of high-end AV processors.
3. Limited Upgradability: Upgrading often means replacing the entire unit rather than individual components.
4. Bulkier Size: Typically larger and may take up more space in the entertainment setup.

Both?

Another solution is to get a receiver and use the built-in amplification for the surround channels and a dedicated amp for the front channels. Then you get the simplicity and cost-effectiveness of the receiver, while the benefit from the dedicated amp.